guild wars is good, but is it good enough?

i was checking out the google hoard of MMO search results, and came across MMORPG.com. a fairly ubiquitous sounding place, with generic features, with the saving grace of it having such things as statistics for what generated the most interest and the like. i'm surprised that the article entailing top 5 games that deserve makeovers didn't list EQ. but on the same token one of the top anticipated games at the moment is guild wars 2. and one of the most popular games of draw for current releases is guild wars. so this's up there. but i can't see it being that amazing considering the limited nature of the game.